A Point of View Should Be Pointy

A clear creative thesis gives an experience a soul.

I believe the gap between good design and great design is wider than most people realize, and that design can make or break an experience. And if we’re committed to designing truly great experiences, I believe the most important thing we can do is take the time to develop a point of view that is pointy.

When I say “pointy,” I don’t mean contrarian or controversial. I mean that a project’s point of view has been honed, and stress-tested, and whittled down until its focus and direction are unmistakable. It is the flag we plant in the ground, the core truth that our experience will embody, and the guiding principle for the decisions that follow. 

We encounter this idea whenever we ask, “What is the point of this?” We’re asking for the essential idea, the thing we’re meant to understand. Or, we might find our way on a long voyage using the “points” of a compass. Both meanings are useful here: a point of view should tell us what matters and where we’re going.  

In modern experience design, this point of view goes by many names: the theme, the core thesis, or one of my favorites, the creative North Star. Whatever we choose to call it, it needs to be a clear guide, with enough conviction to rule some possibilities in and others out. Joe Rohde, Walt Disney Imagineering legend, calls this process thematic cascade: how we carry that core idea through each design decision. It informs everything from the layout of an entire theme park down to the correct amount of patina on a doorknob. 

Clearly defining the project’s point of view gives us something to build around: a perspective that connects story, space, and interaction into a world our guests can inhabit and identify with. It shapes what an experience means, how it feels, and whether people can find a place for themselves within it.

This does more than create helpful creative boundaries for a project. It’s also key to creating an experience with a soul. There's an analogy here with our own sense of self. Sight, sound, sensation, meaning, and memory are integrated in what feels like a single point of awareness. That point of view, that unified sense of identity is what I have in mind when I talk about the soul of an experience. 

A well-crafted experience can have a similar kind of unity: its parts can feel like they belong to one recognizable presence and identity. When we align the different disciplines in a project around one clear point, the experience takes on a life of its own. That spark of life is the difference between good and great design. Great design is not just incrementally better, it goes through a phase change, transforming into something more than the sum of its parts. 

A guest can enter into a relationship with an experience that has a soul. They can recognize a value, become absorbed in a way of seeing, or discover something that feels personally relevant. That is what I mean by inhabiting an experience. Its perspective is clear enough for someone to find their own position in relation to it. Spending time in another point of view can change how we see our own lives. It can help us recognize what matters to us, question something we took for granted, or imagine who we might become. 

One person might contribute to something shared. Another might recognize a value they want to live out more fully in their own life. A clear point of view can support both. The goal of making it pointy is not to make an experience narrow or one-dimensional. Quite the opposite: clarity and precision give different people room to find their own place within a shared narrative. Rohde says, “Clarity on the central theme manufactures autonomy,” and this is true for our creative partners on an experience project as well as for the guests moving through it. 

Projects change as they meet budgets, schedules, physical constraints, and the expertise of the people building them. A moment gets shortened. An element gets added. A decision that made sense in one part of the project changes how another part feels. Each choice may seem reasonable on its own, but the cumulative effect can still weaken the experience. Someone has to keep sight of the whole thing and its alignment with the core idea.

I see that as a central responsibility of creative leadership. We have to keep asking how a decision serves the core idea. The standard should be clear enough that the team understands what we are advocating for. Then, we can put our coordinated energy into finding the strongest way to realize it. Much of the work of closing the gap between good and great happens here: sustained judgment, careful revisions, and a willingness to keep advocating for the point of view.

Maven's experience in branding and design is an amazing foundation for this kind of work. Finding an essential idea, giving it a distinctive identity, and developing a language that carries across different mediums are familiar disciplines. They require a clear understanding of purpose and audience, a particular point of view, and the judgment to keep different expressions connected. Those skills are at the heart of great experience design.

In a physical experience, that thinking extends through space, time, movement, and behavior. We develop it alongside the people responsible for the architecture, fabrication, technical design, AV systems, media production, and operations, so the intent takes shape in what can be built and sustained. Whether we're helping a client define the experience from the beginning or providing design support within a wider team, our role is to help establish a direction people can believe in and be its advocates through opening day.

Every experience deserves a clear point of view and a team with the conviction to see it through. Because in the end, isn’t that what we all want? An experience with a soul, and a place to find and shape ourselves within it?

We’re here to design the unmistakable.

More News
Let’s create something amazing together.
Get in touch